This week’s Tuesdays with Dorie selection was the oh so delectable Coconut Butter Thins. These cookies are so delicate that Dorie Greenspan almost didn’t include them in her book Baking…From My Home to Yours. That would have been a tragedy. These cookies are so buttery with a great crispy texture. These are the kind of cookies you can eat and eat until you are only left with crumbs.
Coconut Butter Thins are a shortbread cookie flavored with coconut, lime, and lots of butter. There is also a hint of coriander which knocks these cookies out of the stratosphere. I don’t recall ever baking with coriander. Now I’m going to add it to my baking repertoire. It paired well with the other flavors and brought them all to the next level.
Instead of squares, I used my round cookie cutters and made little circles. Because of the circle shape, I had dough scraps which I reshaped and made more round cookies until I didn’t have any more scraps. Although these scrappy cookies didn’t hold their shape too well {even after refrigeration} and were a little “ugly”, they were still mighty tasty.
This week I also made Toasted Coconut Ice Cream from David Lebovitz’s The Perfect Scoop and created little ice cream sandwiches. No surprises, the ice cream was great. It’s a custard-based ice cream in which the cream is infused with the flavor of toasted coconut and a scraped vanilla bean {from Tahiti–my supply is getting low, oh no} with a hint of rum. You can find the ice cream recipe HERE.
Thank you to Jayne of The Barefoot Kitchen Witch for selecting this recipe. It’s another winner! Please visit her blog for the recipe.
wow wow wow! could i add 10 more to that? haha. the cookies look absolutely to die for! and the toasted coconut icecream sandwich.. i wish i had one of those… KILLER DESSERT!!!
I love your icecream sandwiches – coconut icecream plus coconut cookies equals delicious!!
You made coconut ice cream to go with them. You’re my hero! They’re beautiful.
il faut ouvrir grand, la bouche pour manger de beaux et gros sandwichs, de même ! Beau travail 🙂
I don’t think they look ugly at all. I like the way they look… cute little circles!
I just plopped mine on a cookie sheet. boring. 🙂
Nice job though!
They look SO GORGEOUS! I swear, looking at the little sandwiches makes me way too hungry for a Tuesday morning…great job!
Wow! I love that you cut them out in circles. They look fabulous. And the ice cream…YUM!
OK, the whole time I was mixing the dough for the cookies I was thinking, I wonder what Wendy is going to do this week? I bet it’s going to be something really, really fabulous. And then I thought, I bet she’ll make ice cream, she likes to make ice cream. And then I thought, oooooooh, I wonder if she’ll make the toasted coconut ice cream from DL? I am obsessed with the idea of that ice cream right now and if I ever get an ice cream maker, it’s going to be my first choice. Haagen-Dazs makes this Pineapple Coconut ice cream that’s so good but I bet that your Toasted Coconut ice cream is even better.
I love the circle shapes and I love your little ice cream sandwiches — they’re absolutely adorable. And, I’m super jealous of your creativity!
Gosh, well done for making the ice-cream too! These look so good, yum!
Oh I love the addition of ice cream with these. I’m afraid mine were too thin to hold up to adding that to them however. We ate them all up anyway. Delicious. Yours are beautiful!!!!
Beautiful! I love that you made an ice cream to go with them.
Love the sandwiches! And the circles are way cuter than my uneven, spreading squares….great job!
beautiful!
Oh! oooooOOOooooooh!
How luscious! Now, if we’re having a luscious contest… you win this week! Hands down…
Beautiful and very, very mouthwatering, Pink!
Coconut ice cream sandwiches? {Whimpers} These look amazing!
Wow, love the ice cream sandwiches!! That toasted coconut ice cream sounds amazing. I need to pull out my copy of The Perfect Scoop and try it!
What a perfect pairing. Great idea.
Yay! I was hoping to see a little ice cream action from you, and you didn’t disappoint! My word, that ice cream had to be amazing with these divine cookies. The perfect ice cream sandwich for the beach!
Yum what a fantastic idea to put that yummy ice cream in the middle. I love it! Your cookies look very good and Im glad you liked them!
Your cookies look delicious! I don’t think they are ugly at all. Ice cream sandwiches sound good about now though! 🙂
splendid! love, love the ice cream sandwiches. and the round cookies are so dainty and delicious looking. i can’t wait to make these when i’m up to baking again:)
Yum!!!!! Great idea with the ice cream sandwiches!
i wouldn’t have thought to use corainder in something sweet either.
There you go again with the ice cream! LOVE IT!
What a fantastic job with the scraps! 😉
These look great as shortbread rounds. And sublime as ice cream sandwiches. Yum! Great job.
Nancy
Oh, wow! Those look incredible. I love coconut and will have to try that ice cream!
These are beautiful!! I love the round shape!
Wowza! That ice cream sounds heavenly!
I really liked the cookies, too, and mine ended up less thin and more shortbready, but they were quite delicious.
Wow! So pretty and creative. I love them.
Your cookies look super nice and yummy!
I didn’t have time to make mine before today but I’m hoping to post them soon.
How perfect…little rounds, and toasted coconut ice cream in the middle. Another Perfect Scoop recipe to try!
I think your cookies look perfect. I might have to make them round next time
Your ice cream sandwiches look fantastic – very creative to combine those flavors!
Coco Loco is right! These look great. I love how you pair yummy ice creams with the baked goodies. Inspirational. 🙂
Wow! These look totally delicious!! I love that you added coconut ice cream between the layers. How perfect!
Gorgeous presentation, as usual. I was wondering how I was going to use the leftover coconut, I may have to make ice cream now.
You are a decadent, decadent woman. And I like that in a baker!
Oh, wow! Your cookies look fantastic! What a great idea to pair them with coconut ice cream. If mine had turned out as perfectly as yours, I might have liked them better! 😉
looks so good! how badly do i wish i had some of that ice cream?!
These were SO GOOD with ice cream and must be amazing with the toasted coconut ice cream!!! They look gorgeous! Drooooooling…..
Oh my, you’re killing me. Those look SO good with the toasted coconut ice cream. Lovely photos, too!
Seriously did you have to make ice cream? Oh man I can’t tell you how wonderful that sounds. Your ice cream sandwiches – WOW. Now I must go make that ice cream! And more cookies too. Wonderful job.
I love that you made ice cream sandwiches with these cookies. I bet they were delicious!
That was genius making ice cream sandwiches!
About two weeks ago I purchased The Perfect Scoop & perfect it is. There were two of you (blogs) that kept raving about it as well as another blog that kept pumping out the ice cream….I caved. I also ordered an extra freezer bowl from my cuisinart ice cream maker!
~ingrid
Nice job with the ice cream sandwiches — sounds and looks so delicious!
I love the rounds…and coconut ice cream?! The Perfect Scoop is going to be my next cookbook purchase for sure
the rounds and the ice cream.. amazing! keep those good ideas coming!
Coconut ice cream sandwiches. Perfect. I used to love the Coconut ice cream from Howard Johnsons. This sounds just as good. Thanks for the recipe.
Those cookies look just right.
Oh my goodness! I think you kicked these out of the stratosphere by adding in homemade coconut ice cream. You ought to be able to move up at least one spot in the TWD recipe rotation for that one, LOL.
Oh, and I also love the round cookies… those are much neater than the squares (my squares anyway).
Truly exquisite looking. The ice cream cookie combo had to be out of this world.
yours look so perfect! mine spread into misshapen blogs. yum, toasted coconut ice cream.
oops – i meant misshapen BLOBS, not blogs. 🙂
Love the round cookies. What did you do with the scraps?
I served mine with some lemon gelato.
I love your perfectly round cookies – they look much nicer than the squares that Dorie recommends, in my opinion. And with coconut ice cream? Yum!
Sadly, I don’t like coconut, so I wouldn’t like the ice cream. But it was a great idea to make ice cream sandwiches with your cookies! I usually make round shortbread cookies, too.
How delicious! I love the ice cream sandwiches. I’ve been dying to try David Lebovitz’s Salted Caramel Ice Cream.